Is your cat giving Marro the cold shoulder? Don't worry, it's actually normal behaviour, and doesn't mean they're never going to love Marro. In fact, we're pretty sure they will!
We’ve got plenty of helpful tips and tricks to guide you (and your cat) through the journey from fussy to foodie.
WHY CATS CAN BE CAUTIOUS WITH NEW FOOD
Cats aren't being difficult - they're being instinctual. As natural hunters, cats are wired to be cautious of new foods to avoid anything potentially harmful. Here’s what might be influencing your cat’s appetite:
Neophobia: it's really common for cats fear new things, including new smells and textures in their food.
Stress: even subtle changes in their environment (like a new scent, guest, or furniture shuffle) can reduce appetite.
Texture & smell: cats are highly sensitive to food texture and temperature. Freshly cooked meals like Marro may take a little getting used to.
Health issues: if your cat is consistently refusing food, it's always worth speaking with your vet to rule out underlying conditions.
THE 3-DAY MARRO TRANSITION PLAN
We’ve found that many cats respond best with a short and simple 3-day approach. This gives them time to get used to their new meals, and gives them the best chance for success. Here’s how to introduce Marro in a way that builds curiosity and confidence:
DAY 1:
Try Succulent Chicken first - it's our most loved recipe.
Warm a spoonful slightly (about 10 seconds in the microwave) to release aromas and get that gravy flowing.
Serve on a flat plate they're used to, removing any other food at the same time.
Place it in a calm, familiar feeding spot.
Don’t worry if your cat walks away - this is normal.
DAY 2:
Repeat the same setup: same plate, same spot, same amount. Stick to chicken again.
Your cat is more likely to sniff, explore, or nudge the food today.
DAY 3:
Most cats will start eating by now. If they’re still unsure, keep trying, and keep things going in the same routine - many cats just need a little longer to adjust.
Marro top tip: Consistency is key. Don’t switch back and forth between recipes or methods too quickly. Let the routine build familiarity.
TOP TIPS TO ENCOURAGE HEALTHY EATING HABITS
Serve small, frequent meals
Cats naturally eat small “prey-sized” meals. Try 3–4 mini meals throughout the day to align with their instincts.
Warm it up
Cats prefer food at “prey temperature” (a bit warmer than room temp). This boosts aroma and makes Marro even more tempting.
Stimulate their inner hunter
Play with your cat before meals—think feathers, string toys, or laser pointers. It gets their appetite going and mimics the hunt–eat cycle.
Keep mealtimes clean and calm
Wash bowls daily with non-scented soap.
Avoid feeding near litter trays or noisy areas.
Freshen water daily and serve it in a separate bowl.
Make meals fun
Use puzzle feeders, lick mats, or hide small plates of Marro around the house. Cats enjoy working for their food - it’s mentally enriching and rewarding.
Rotate recipes after transition
If, after the 3-day transition, your cat isn't keen on one recipe, introduce a different one. Keep any rejected recipes frozen for now and try offering them again in a week or so, you might find they come back around later.
YOU'RE NOT ALONE
Every cat is different, and adjusting to a Fresh, gently cooked food like Marro can take a little time. Stick with it, follow the tips above, and remember - we're always here to help.
You can also join our Facebook community, the Marro Supper Club where you can connect with other cat humans feeding Marro, share tips, and see photos of gorgeous cats (don't let your cat see looking...)