Skip to main content

What are ACH Returns?

This article explains ACH returns and provides an overview of how they are managed in Nickel.

An ACH return occurs when an Automated Clearing House (ACH) payment is reversed due to rejection by either the receiving or issuing bank. When a transaction is rejected, the ACH network generates a return code that indicates the reason for the failure. Common reasons include insufficient funds, incorrect account details, or account restrictions.

When a payment is rejected after it was already included in a payout to you, Nickel records the return as a separate transaction. For example, if a customer pays your company through the Nickel Payments Portal, a transaction labeled Customer Payment appears on the Transactions page. If that payment is later rejected, a second transaction for the same amount is created and labeled Customer Payment Returned. If the payment is rejected before it is paid out to you, no second transaction is created: the original Customer Payment is marked as failed instead.

Returns on money going out work the same way. If a payment to one of your vendors is rejected, the return is labeled Vendor Payment Returned. You can see all of them together on the Returns tab of the Transactions page.

Refunded payments will be under the Refunds tab.

While viewing an ACH return in Nickel, you can select the View Original Payment link to open the payment that was returned.

The Failure Reason returned by the ACH network appears on the Detail tab of the original payment.

What Happens After a Return

What you need to do depends on why the payment came back:

  • Insufficient funds. These are retryable. The account is fine, there just was not enough money in it at the time, so the payment can be attempted again.
    ​

  • Authorization problems. The account works, but the debit was not allowed. If the account holder revoked or disputed the debit, Nickel will not debit that saved account again until the customer authorizes a new payment. If the payer's bank blocked the debit (R29), retrying the same account will keep failing until the bank allows Nickel's debits. See What is ACH Return Code R29 for how to clear a debit block with the payer's bank.
    ​

  • Account problems. If the account is closed, frozen, cannot be located, or the routing number is wrong, every future debit to those numbers will bounce too.

Note: When a bill payment is returned for one of those account problems, Nickel removes that bank account from your saved payment methods automatically. Your history is kept, but you will need to use another payment method or add a working bank account before you can pay bills again. This is deliberate, since further attempts against the same account are guaranteed to fail.

Need help?

If you have questions, please chat with our team via the Help Center when you login to the platform.

For more information on ACH returns, including explanations of the most common ACH return codes, see ACH Returns: Why they happen and how to deal with them.

Did this answer your question?