Skip to main content

Cash vs accrual, and the fiscal year

Two association-wide settings shape every financial report in PayHOA: the accounting method (cash or accrual) decides when income and…

M
Written by Michael Bollinger

Two association-wide settings shape every financial report in PayHOA: the accounting method (cash or accrual) decides when income and expenses count, and the fiscal year decides where your year starts and ends. This article explains what each one changes, how to set them, and what happens at year end.

Before you start: Both settings are in Settings (the gear icon at the top right), which only association admins can open: the accounting method is on the Preferences tab and the fiscal year on the Organization Settings tab. Talk to your accountant or treasurer before you change either one: both change reports you've already run, including past years.

Check or change your accounting method

  1. Go to Settings (the gear icon at the top right) → Preferences.

  2. In the Report Preferences card, under Preferred Accounting Method:, choose Cash or Accrual. The hint underneath says what the choice means:

    • Cash: Count income from invoices when payments are received

    • Accrual: Count income from invoices when they become active

  3. Click Update settings. You see Settings were updated.

This is one setting for the whole association. There's no cash or accrual switch on the report pages; every financial report uses this setting.

What the method changes

Cash

Accrual

Owner income

Counts when the money comes in, on the date of the approved bank deposit it arrived in. Money paid before the invoice is active waits in Prepayments until the active date.

Counts on the invoice's active date, whether or not it's paid yet

Expenses from payables

Count when the bill is paid, on the payment date

Count on the payable's invoice date once you confirm it; unpaid bills sit in Accounts Payable

Money an owner pays before it's due

Shows as income in the Prepayments category until it's applied to an invoice

Sits in the Prepaid Revenue liability until the invoice is active. (The older accounting version calls this line Accounts Receivable - Prepaids.)

Forgiven invoices and credits you grant

Don't touch income or expenses, because no money moved

Post to the Bad Debt and Account Credits expense categories

Balance sheet

No Accounts Receivable, Funds in Transit, Undeposited Funds, Prepaid Revenue or Accounts Payable

All of those show

Categories on reports

Bad Debt and Account Credits are left off

Prepayments is left off

Important: On cash basis, a check or cash payment you recorded only counts as income once it's linked to a bank deposit and that deposit is approved on Transactions. If it's never linked, it never shows on the cash-basis P&L, even though the owner's balance went down. See Link owner payments to deposits.

The method changes the Balance Sheet, Trial Balance, General Ledger, Account Register, the profit and loss reports, the budget reports and the Budget Overview page. Reports about owners and payments, such as Aging of Accounts, Delinquent Accounts, the unit balance reports and Payments by Unit, work the same on either method: they're built from invoices and payments, not from income and expense.

For what a cash-basis Prepayments line on your P&L means, see Reports: common questions. For how payables post, see How payables show up in your books.

What happens when you switch

On Accounting V2, PayHOA keeps a cash version and an accrual version of every ledger entry all the time. Switching the method doesn't re-post anything; your reports read the other version straight away. That means:

  • Every report changes at once, including past months and past years. A P&L you gave the board last year won't match the same P&L run today.

  • Nothing is lost. Switching back shows the old numbers again.

Pick the method your accountant files on and leave it there. If you're switching at a year end, save PDFs of last year's reports first.

On the older accounting version: income that came in through the bank feed rather than as an owner payment only counts on accrual if the transaction has Outside Revenue ticked. Outside Revenue means income that didn't come from an owner's invoice in PayHOA, such as bank interest. Accrual reports leave income transactions out unless they're marked, so that an owner payment isn't counted twice (once from its invoice and once from its bank deposit). To mark one, open the transaction on Transactions, or add it with Add transaction, pick an income category and tick Outside Revenue. The box only shows on accrual basis once an income category is picked. Before you switch to accrual, check those deposits on Transactions. There's also a Charge Date for Prepaids: setting on the Preferences page (Active Date / Due Date) that decides which invoice date prepayments are measured against. Neither exists on Accounting V2.

"My accrual P&L shows a whole year of dues in one month"

On accrual, an invoice counts on its active date. If you bill annual dues as one invoice dated January 1, the whole year's income lands in January, and the rest of the year shows none.

To spread it out:

On cash, the same dues count in the months owners actually pay.

Income or an expense landed in the wrong year

On cash basis, income counts in the year the money reaches your bank and an expense counts in the year you pay it, whichever year it was meant for. An owner who pays January's dues in December (prepaid dues or prepaid assessments) adds to December's income, and an insurance premium paid in December for next year is this year's expense. On accrual basis, owner income follows the invoice's active date, so prepaid dues already count in the right year and wait in the Prepaid Revenue liability until then.

To move income or an expense into another fiscal year, post two journal entries through a holding account: a Prepaid Dues liability for income, or a Prepaid Expenses asset for an expense. The steps, the dates to use and when you don't need them are in Move income or expenses to another fiscal year.

Set your fiscal year

Your fiscal year can start in any month. You can set it in two places; both change the same setting.

In Settings:

  1. Go to Settings (the gear icon at the top right) → Organization Settings.

  2. On the Organization Information card, pick a month under Fiscal Period Start.

  3. Click Update. You see Settings were updated.

From a report or the budget:

  1. On any report with date chips, click the gear on the Last FY or This FY chip (Configure fiscal year start). On Budget Overview, choose Fiscal under Type and click the settings icon next to it.

  2. The Organization fiscal period dialog opens: Choose when your fiscal year starts. This will update anywhere you have fiscal year settings.

  3. Pick the month under Fiscal year starts and click Save. You see Fiscal period updated.

If you see Failed to update fiscal period., your account can't change it; ask an association admin. Having Reports or Budgets access isn't enough to save the fiscal year.

What the fiscal year controls

  • The Last FY and This FY date chips on every report.

  • The fiscal-year date options in report packets and scheduled reports, such as Start of fiscal year.

  • The Year-to-date basis on Budget Performance by Month, and the fiscal-year view on Budget Overview (for example Fiscal year (Jul-Jun)).

  • On the Trial Balance, income and expense accounts add up from the start of the fiscal year.

  • On the Balance Sheet, where Net Income stops and Retained Earnings begins (below).

It doesn't change the month pickers when you create a draft budget; you choose those months yourself. See Create a draft budget.

Year end: Net Income and Retained Earnings

What happens at year end depends on which accounting version your association is on. You're on Accounting V2, the current one, if your Reports page has a Trial Balance report. You're on the older version if it doesn't, and the Balance Sheet and General Ledger show an Update now link under the page title. See Which version am I on?

On Accounting V2 there's nothing to do at year end. PayHOA closes the year for you on every balance sheet:

  • Net Income is income minus expenses from the start of the fiscal year to the balance sheet's date.

  • Retained Earnings is everything before the start of the fiscal year: all earlier years' net income, plus any journal entries you posted to Retained Earnings yourself.

On the first day of a new fiscal year, last year's net income moves into Retained Earnings and Net Income starts again from zero. No closing entry is posted; the split is worked out each time you run the report.

Because of this:

  • Don't post your own closing journal entries. Moving income and expense balances into Retained Earnings by hand empties those categories on last year's P&L.

  • If you change the fiscal start month, every balance sheet is split again on the new month, including past ones. Total equity stays the same; only the line between Net Income and Retained Earnings moves.

  • A balance sheet's Net Income is year-to-date, so it won't match a one-month P&L. Run the P&L from the start of the fiscal year to compare. See Balance sheet and trial balance.

  • An equity account you created yourself for earlier years, for example Prior Years' Net Income, isn't updated at year end. Only PayHOA's own Retained Earnings account collects each finished year's result, on top of any starting balance you gave it. To keep one line, move your opening figure into the Starting balance of Retained Earnings and set your own account's starting balance to 0. See How do I adjust a prior-years' net income or retained earnings account.

  • There's no closing date and no way to lock a finished year. Entries dated in last year can still be added, changed or deleted, and last year's reports change with them, so save PDFs of your year-end reports. See Can I lock a closed month or year, or set a closing date?

On the older accounting version: the year isn't closed for you, and the automatic answer above doesn't apply: the year is closed by hand with journal entries. Contact PayHOA's accounting support (accounting@payhoa.com or 859-249-8828, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm Eastern Time) before you close the year, give your fiscal year's end date and ask for the year-end closing steps; they'll walk you through the journal entries.

What's next

Did this answer your question?