Skip to main content

9. Member Retention & Win-Back Playbook

A proactive approach to keeping members longer without discounting your way out of churn.

Pipeline Solutions Support avatar
Written by Pipeline Solutions Support
Updated over 3 weeks ago

Who this is for

  • Owners

  • Managers

  • Retention-focused teams


Why this matters

Retention is not a campaign — it’s a habit.

Pipeline helps you see:

  • Who’s slipping

  • When to act

  • How to follow up


How to do this in Pipeline

Step 1: Monitor Low-Engagement Members

This is your early warning system.


Step 2: Assign Human Outreach

No automation replaces care.

Create Tasks for:

  • Personal texts

  • Quick calls

  • In-studio check-ins


Step 3: Log Outcomes

So you learn what works.


How to Approach At-Risk Members (High-Intent, Low-Volume)

What we mean by “At-Risk”

At-risk members are not just “less active.”

They are members who:

  • Have dropped attendance meaningfully

  • Have broken a once-consistent habit

  • Have silently disengaged

These members are far more likely to churn — and also far more sensitive to how you show up.


Why this requires a different approach

At-risk outreach is not:

  • A blast

  • A script

It is:

  • Intentional

  • Human

  • Slower — on purpose

Trying to “clear” at-risk members in bulk often accelerates churn.


The Weekly At-Risk Member Focus

Best practice:
Tackle 1–2 at-risk members per week, no more.

This keeps outreach:

  • Thoughtful

  • Personal

  • Sustainable

Retention happens through quality, not volume.


Step 1: Choose the Right Members

Once per week, identify:

  • 1–2 members whose engagement has dropped sharply

  • Members who previously showed strong consistency

Operator mindset:
Start with the members who have a more recent drop off.


Step 2: Understand the Context Before Reaching Out

Before contacting them, review:

  • Attendance history

  • Last interaction

  • Notes from previous conversations

This prevents:

  • Tone-deaf outreach

  • Repeating old questions

  • Making the member feel forgotten


Step 3: Reach Out Personally (Not Perfectly)

This is not about conversion language.

Good outreach sounds like:

  • Curiosity

  • Care

  • Familiarity

Examples:

  • “Hey [Name], you crossed my mind this week, how have things been?”

No pressure. No pitch.


Step 4: Create Space for a Response

At-risk members may:

  • Reply slowly

  • Share something personal

  • Not respond at all

All outcomes are data.

If they respond:

  • Listen first

  • Log the context in Pipeline (Client Notes)

  • Create a follow-up task if appropriate


Step 5: Close the Loop Intentionally

Regardless of outcome:

  • Log the interaction

  • Note what you learned

  • Avoid repeated outreach unless invited

Retention is about trust, not persistence.


What “good” looks like

  • Fewer silent cancellations

  • Stronger relationships

  • Higher lifetime value


Common mistakes to avoid

  • Waiting until cancellation notice

  • Over-automating outreach


Next step

Did this answer your question?