Skip to main content

Workshop - Peer Review

Set up of a Workshop Activity

Updated over 7 months ago

Purpose

Moodle’s Workshop activity allows students to assess each other's work anonymously. Students can also practice with examples, if necessary. The peer reviewers can be set up randomly, or defined by the instructor.

Resources

* Moodle.org provides instructions, including a video. This optional video demo does not match our tutorial, but may help in supplementing our instructions below: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nT_u6lhuitM

Procedure

In Moodle, add the Workshop activity from the Activity Chooser.

NOTE: The student names are hidden from each other. If you want students to remain anonymous, tell them to take their name off of the assignment.

If you want the student to see each other’s names, just tell them to include it on the materials they post. This includes the assessment they provide. The instructor always sees the student names.

Arrow pointing to the Workshop activity in the Activity Chooser.

The Workshop Phases

Click the arrow to the left of the title to open article sections

Setup

Provide a Workshop name.

Provide a Description of this activity. Students will only see this during the Setup Phase of the Workshop.

Grading settings

Decide how you want the submissions to be graded. There are four standard methods. However, the simple Number of errors is best for a basic workshop. We recommend you click the “?” in the circle to read about them.

NOTE: Workshops have two grades. The grade students receive from submitting and the grade they receive for the quality of their assessment.

Grading settings section with number of errors selected for Grading strategy.

Submission settings

Add instructions for students.

Decide how many (if any) files may be uploaded and the types and size of files allowed.

Submission settings section

Assessment settings

Provide instructions for the peer assessment.

Assessment settings section

Feedback

Provide an overall conclusion and/or file attachments at the end of the Workshop activity.

Feedback settings section with Enabled and optional selected under Overall feedback mode.

Example submission

Useful if students are new to the workshop and need practice assessing.

Example submissions section with "Example submissions are provided for practice in assessing" check marked and "Assessment of example submission is voluntary" are selected.

Next, complete your selections for the remaining sections on the settings page. These are similar to sections for other activities (e.g. Availability, Common module settings, etc.).

Click Save and display at the bottom of the page to continue setting up the Workshop activity.

The summary of the Setup phase is displayed.

Next, set up your Assessment Form.

Click Edit assessment form.

Setup phase with "Edit assessment form" highlighted in the list of steps.

Edit assessment form

NOTE: Depending on the option chosen for the grading strategy, the terminology will be either Aspect, Assertion, or Criterion.

Add Instructions in the Description fields for as many Aspects, Assertion, or Criterion as you require.

Each Aspect, Assertion, or Criterion includes its own grading scale.

Set the grades for each. More grade items can be added, as needed.

Save the page when you are finished adding the grade items.

Aspect 3 shown with "Best possible grade/Scale to use" highlighted.

Submission

The Submission phase is the 2nd part of the workshop.

It is best to review the Allocation options now, before activating the Workshop assignment in your course.

Click the Submission phase radio button to review the Allocation options for the Submission phase.

Switch to the submission phase radio button highlighted

Submission phase

When instructors switch to the submission phase, students will be able to submit their work. Look at the green arrows to ensure all tasks are completed.

Before moving to the assessment phase, the instructor must decide how the submissions will be allocated.

Click on the Allocate submissions link in the Submission phase.

Submission phase with "Allocate submissions" highlighted.

Manual, Random, and Scheduled Allocations

Choose one of the three allocation methods

Dropdown menu showing options for Manual allocation, Random allocation, and Scheduled allocation.

Manual allocation (Best for small classes)

Allocate students to review a classmate’s project. This is best for a small class, or if you know your students well and want to control certain allocations.

Students have to submit work before you can assign reviewers.

Choose the dropdowns to select the reviewers and the reviewees.

Random allocation

(Best for large classes)

This is useful if you have large classes, or if you don’t want to be personally involved in the selections. Choose either a number per submission, or a number per reviewer.

Random allocation settings page

You can also allow students to assess without submitting anything.

Scheduled allocation (Set number of reviews based on submission reviews)

Scheduled allocation settings page with Number of reviews dropdown open and an arrow pointing to "Participants can access without having submitted anything" checkbox.

We’ve found that this is the best option to use if you are not going to manually select the peer reviewers. Bypass the other two tabs and go directly to Scheduled allocation.

Check-mark the “Automatically allocate…“ sentence.

Next, scroll to the Allocation settings section.

If you want each student to have at least one paper to review, choose “per reviewer” from the dropdown. If you don’t choose “per reviewer”, some students may not get a paper to review.

Choose whether participants can assess without submitting anything.


Assessment

In this phase, students assess the work of their peers and the instructor monitors the process.

NOTE: It is essential the assessment criteria are easy to understand and unambiguous. Much of the success of the workshop activity depends on the students’ understanding of the peer assessment criteria.

Assessment phase.

The Student Point of View during peer assessment

During the Assessment phase, students will click on the Assess button. They will complete the Assessment form by answering the questions you listed in each Aspect, Assertion, or Criterion.

The “assessor’s” name will be hidden from the classmate they are reviewing. You can tell them to “sign” in the feedback section if you want their name to be revealed to their classmate.

You may have also allow the student to post Overall feedback for their peer.

Aspect 3 settings page

CLICK HERE to view a sample of the student experience.


Grading Evaluation

Grading evaluation phase

Check the grades

The assessment grade is calculated by, “Comparison with the best assessment,” found on the Workshop settings page.

The grade for assessment is determined by comparing the grade a student gave for each submission, with the grades other participants gave.

The default for Comparison of assessments is fair, but can be changed from very lax to very strict.

This is also where the instructor can edit individual student grades, if needed.

Grading evaluation settings

NOTE: Be sure to click on the Re-calculate grades button before moving on to the next phase!

Re-calculate grades button

Grades will not appear in the gradebook for the students if you skip this step.

If you need to override a grade, it will appear in a different color.

Workshop grades report

Override Grades - Manually Set Grades

Workshop grades report with arrows pointing to the students name to grade submission and arrow pointing to assessment grade to grade student assessment

To override grades, click on the Submission title to grade the student’s submission.

Click on the Grade under the Grades Given column to grade the student’s assessment.

Update the Grade for the Submission or the Assessment (peer review)

After you update or post a grade, scroll down and Save.

Assessment settings section. Select new grade from dropdown.
Feedback for the author section. Select new grade from dropdown.


Closed

Even if you have chosen an end date for the Workshop settings, you have to click on the Close workshop radio button in order for the grades to be posted for your students.

Closed phase

When the workshop is closed, the two grades will appear in the gradebook in separate columns.

Grader report page

This tutorial is based on Moodle.org instructions, which includes a step-by-step video. https://docs.moodle.org/38/en/Workshop_activity.

Please contact the Moodle Team if you need further assistance!

Did this answer your question?