Skip to main content

Review Policy

Mandycore the Manticore avatar
Written by Mandycore the Manticore
Updated yesterday

Reviews provided by players are an essential part of StartPlaying. They make it easier for players to find the right GM for them, and provide your GM essential feedback to help them level up!

We want all reviews on StartPlaying to be be genuine, informative, and constructive.

StartPlaying Review Policy

To keep reviews fair for everyone, the following items are not permitted in a review on StartPlaying:


Review Extortion/Manipulation

  • Reviews on StartPlaying may not be given or held in exchange for refunds, discounts, or a promise not to take a negative action against someone else.

    • Game Masters may not promise a Player a full refund if they change their review from 1 star to 5 stars.

    • Players may not withhold a review for the purpose of forcing a desired outcome from their Game Master.

Violations of StartPlaying Policy

  • Reviews may not contain content that violates our Terms of Service, Code of Conduct, or Privacy Policy, including but not limited to:

    • Personal Attacks that cannot be reasonably viewed as Constructive Criticism

    • Explicit Language or Obscenities

    • Hate Speech

    • Implied or Explicit Threats or Intimidation

    • Personally Identifiable Information

Parts of the Game that are Outside of the Game Master’s Control

  • Reviews should accurately reflect the experience that the Game Master provided you.

  • Reviews may not be about parts of your game that the Game Master can not reasonably be expected to control.

    • If your computer does not have the right specifications to run the Virtual Table Top (VTT) the Game Master has listed for your game, and you experience technical difficulties during your game due to this, your Game Master is not liable for this.

Misinformation About Game Listings

  • Reviews may not be about issues with games that were correctly disclosed in the game listing.

    • If a Player leaves a review saying they hated that a game was Play by Post rather than a live game, and it was clearly stated in the listing that the game was Play by Post, then the Game Master is not liable for this.

StartPlaying Website Errors

  • Reviews should be about your experience with your Game Master, not your experience with the StartPlaying website.

  • Reviews may not contain content that is specifically about StartPlaying as a website, including but not limited to:

    • Website Bugs and/or Outages

    • Feedback on StartPlaying Policy

Manipulating the Marketplace

  • Reviews may not be used in an attempt to artificially boost your own standing on StartPlaying.

    • Game Masters may not post biased reviews of themselves using alternative accounts to inflate their own review numbers.

StartPlaying Review Investigations

StarPlaying will only remove a review if it violates our Review Policy. StartPlaying will not remove reviews due to a difference of opinion or a disagreement with the sentiment expressed by a player.

If a Game Master believes a review violates the above policy, they can email support@startplayinggames.com for the Support Goblins team to investigate.

Please include in your email:

  • Additional context about the review

  • Screenshots/screen recordings of sessions that can provide additional evidence

If a review is found to be in violation of the Review Policy, it will be removed from the website. If it does not violate our policies, it will put back on the Game Master's profile.

Did this answer your question?