Skip to main content

Why does a third-party tool show a high spam rate during warmup?

Why an external warmup or inbox-placement tool may report a high spam rate even with little or no real sending, and why it can differ from your dashboard's reputation indicator.

It can be alarming to see a third-party warmup or inbox-placement tool report a high spam rate — sometimes even when you've only been warming up and haven't sent real campaigns yet. In most cases this is normal and doesn't mean something is broken.

During warmup, some emails are expected to land in spam

Warmup works by sending and interacting with seed emails to build your sending reputation. Early on, before a mailbox has much history, it's normal for a portion of those emails to land in spam. The number usually improves as warmup continues, which is why warmup should run continuously for the full period rather than being paused or judged too early.

A weak warmup pool is the most common cause

If a tool such as Mailivery or Mailwarm reports a high spam percentage on mailboxes that have sent zero campaign emails, the usual cause is a weak warmup pool in that tool — not a problem with your domain. Switch warmup to one of the pools we currently recommend — Instantly, EmailBison or PlusVibe — at 50–80/day; placement typically recovers within a few days. Please don't use Smartlead for warmup on Maildoso mailboxes (it's fine for sending campaigns). See What makes a warmup pool good.

Placement varies by provider and recipient type

  • Inbox placement is often very different between providers — strong at Outlook but weaker at Gmail, or the reverse.

  • Tests against business (B2B) addresses read differently from tests against personal (B2C) inboxes; Maildoso is built for B2B.

  • A single snapshot from one tool, against one set of test inboxes, isn't always representative of how real recipients receive your mail.

Why it can differ from your dashboard scores

Your dashboard's Google and Microsoft scores come from our own placement tests, while an external tool reports its own test at a moment in time, so they won't always agree. A mismatch is common and usually isn't a concern on its own. See Mailbox reputation scores.

What you can do

  • Keep warmup running continuously at the recommended volume and give it the full 14 days before judging the results.

  • Don't jump to campaign sending before warmup is done, and keep campaigns within the recommended 15/day per mailbox.

  • Re-test consistently (same tool, same conditions) so you're comparing like with like.

  • Make sure your content and sending settings follow good cold-email practice — see How to level up your deliverability.

If a high spam rate persists well beyond warmup, or you see it in real campaigns, contact us with your account email and the domains or mailboxes involved, or book a free Deliverability audit from the top bar of your dashboard. Related: Mailboxes or domains show as "burned", "blacklisted" or low reputation.

Did this answer your question?